What can we do for you?
- Identify the many Myths in the financial system, including the dream of “beating the market” through individual stock selection.
- Identify the key factors to becoming better do-it-yourself investors AND identify those which are under your control, such as an optimum allocation of your investments across appropriate asset categories.
- Accompany you each step of the way in the saving and investment process- see our User Guide.
- Help self-investors to better control their costs, what Warren Buffett calls the financial system’s friction costs.
- Help you better use your tax-exempt (RRSP) account.
- Show you how to minimize your tax-related investment costs.
- Give you access to information to help you better manage a portfolio intended to constitute an important source of retirement income.
- Identify areas where the financial system does not adequately take into account the interests of independent investors.
- Encourage reforms to the regulatory system.
Help us to help you become a better independent investor. Your comments
are appreciated and welcomed on our commentaries or on any other aspect of the site- not only what you find but also how it is presented. In addition, we specifically ask for your input at various points throughout our site.
For more details on the choice and meaning of the symbols click here.
WELCOME to our site for the independent investor which was officially
launched March 18, 2008. Become a member (it’s free) and enjoy full
access to the site + receive on a preferred basis our weekly
newsletters. Our site has been described as one of the few educational
websites that offer the unbiased, clearly written material that busy
investors need (The Globe & Mail 30 05 2008) and as a site dedicated
to providing individual investors with independent, objective, free
advice and information (The Gazette, Montreal 31 03 2008). See In the Media under the tab Media on our home page. MEMBERS-PLEASE NOTE: Depending on your software and internet provider, it may be necessary for you to add http://independentinvestor.info
to your list of safe contacts in your spam filters. Otherwise, you may
not receive our newsletters. Our newsletters notify our members in
priority of our commentaries on current events and other topics of
interest. If you miss a newsletter, it will eventually be filed on the
site at a later date under Information on the home page. We are also on Twitter under DIYInvestor.
Mutual fund costs matter, all thirteen of them
Page 1 of 3Morningstar has recently explained how the level of reported fund expenses is the best reverse predictor of fund performance i.e. the higher the expenses, the worse the likely return. But reported expenses do not represent all fund costs. Without full information an investor considering an actively-managed fund manager who (hopefully) will beat the market is in a dilemma. He has no way of knowing by how much any particular fund manager must beat its benchmark index pre-fees and costs to produce a market-beating return. This first commentary looks at the Morningstar study, and introduces the (unlucky) thirteen different types of fees and expenses that fund investors can be hit with. In subsequent commentaries we will try to quantify the aggregate all-in, after-tax annual cost to equity mutual fund investors; give a more detailed analysis of the 13 types of fund fees and expenses; and describe the profile of the ideal mutual fund (and ETF) from the perspective of minimizing aggregate fund costs.
Retail investors can invest directly or through mutual funds or ETF’s. In making that decision costs are a key consideration. Figuring out the costs of direct investing are fairly straight forward. Figuring out fund costs and their impact on investor returns is not.
Morningstar report on fund expenses
The fund evaluation company Morningstar recently released a study or as PDF
doc.1762 on the relation between mutual fund expenses levels and investor returns in the USA. Here is how they proceeded:
We took a snapshot of star ratings and expense ratios from 2005 through 2008 and then tracked their progress through March 2010. We rolled up category level data into five broad asset classes: domestic equity, international equity, balanced, taxable bond, and municipal bond. We then measured total returns as of the end of March 2010 for the mutual funds that survived the entire period. For the success ratio, we included funds that were merged or liquidated, as well as those that survived, in order to calculate the number that both survived and outperformed. For the star rating, we recorded the five-year star rating for the data set from 2005, as well as the three-year rating. For 2006 and 2007, we recorded the ensuing three-year rating--meaning we measured the figure in March 2009 for the class of 2006 and the rating in March 2010 for the class of 2007. For the class of 2008, we don't yet have a star rating. For the purpose of this article, I focus on the gap between 1- and 5-star funds and cheapest and most expensive quintiles. NB- Although not stated, we believe the study used the MER as the measure of fund expense levels; more about MER’s later.
If there's anything in the whole world of mutual funds that you can take to the bank, it's that expense ratios help you make a better decision. In every single time period and data point tested, low-cost funds beat high-cost funds. … Expense ratios are strong predictors of performance. In every asset class over every time period, the cheapest quintile produced higher total returns than the most expensive quintile.
But should we be surprised?
In most businesses, you pay more to get more. But in the mutual fund business, you get what you don’t pay for, or stated otherwise, less is better. The Morningstar study received considerable attention; see NYT editorial
or as PDF
doc.1763; Richards NYT
or as a PDF doc.1764; Hougan IndexUniverse
or as a PDF
doc.1765; Hale MarketWatch
or as a PDF doc.1766; a AbnormalReturn
video ; and in the WallStreetJournal
The Morningstar conclusions are not really news. The study in fact merely confirms previous studies; see for example a 2002 US study by Stephan Sharkansky of PersonalFund.com or as a PDF
doc.1767. And a 2005 study by Hocjachka or as a PDF
doc.1768 and a more recent 2008 study by Bauer and Kicken
(see in particular table 5) doc.1271 came to the similar conclusions for Canadian funds.
But if expenses are so critical, it should be easy to calculate them and select mutual funds or ETFs accordingly. But unfortunately, things are not so simple. In this first commentary we look at the different types fund expenses, fees and other deductions (which for convenience we sometimes simplify refer to as expenses or costs) faced by fund investors, the difficulties in computing them, their impact on fund returns, and some practical recommendations.
Last Updated ( Sunday, 21 November 2010 )
Your efforts have paid off.
You have ended up on a site which is focused on delivering investment information, not selling you financial services or products. Our site is not associated with, and accepts no financing, advertising or other financial assistance from:
- Insurance companies
- Investment dealers or
- Financial advisors.
- Help you become a better independent self investor.
- Be a source of free, objective, independent and unbiased investment information for self-investors.
- Build on our past to earn the trust of Canadian and non-Canadian do-it-yourself investors. Our founder has several years experience with a securities regulatory agency and over a quarter century of experience with two blue chip Canadian securities issuers.
- For more, see Who are we?
Learn more about us
- we are on Twitter under DIYInvestor
- Take 15 minutes to read the Summary.
- To assess the credibility of our site. It’s the best investment decision you will make today.
- The information on self investing is divided into 44 sections (and counting) which are organized under eleven main headings or topics. Click on Themes at the top of this page for a short summary of the information covered under all of the topics.
- For a list of the sections under any particular theme, click on the name of that theme at the top of this page.
Who should visit our site?
- You are an independent investor looking for investment information focused on the needs of do-it-yourself investors.
- You are a novice in investment matters, but are considering becoming more independent in your investing.
- You trade in reliance on a financial advisor, but wish to better use his services, or perhaps understand the other alternative trading methods.
- Perhaps you see self investing as a retirement project, or are merely curious about the world of investing.
- Perhaps as a result of your professional activities (institutional investor, broker, professor or journalist), you seek access to a non-industry source of objective investment information.
We intend to regularly circulate by email newsletters to our members. To access our newsletter, click here. We are also on Twitter at http://twitter.com/DIYinvestor. Our Newsletters typically contain an in-depth commentary on a timely subject. The most recent commentaries are on our home page. Older commentaries can be found in our Archives, where they can be found by scrolling through the headings or by using the Search function.